Homeowners hold about 43 times the wealth of renters. The Federal Reserve’s 2025 Survey of Consumer Finances puts the median owner at $458,900 and the median renter at $10,600. In 2022, the gap was 38 times.
So is owning a home a good investment? The gap says owners come out ahead, and I’ll show you why. Whether your house is still pulling its weight is a separate question. Dallas-area prices slipped 0.79% over the year ending in August (Case-Shiller), and your equity is probably the biggest pile of money you have in one place.
Your equity usually only matters if you’re selling or refinancing. Most homeowners barely spend any time thinking about it, but if you’re treating it like an investment, you should be looking at it at least annually. Here’s how you can measure what your equity earns against the S&P 500.
If you’re one of my past clients, I do an annual equity review for each and every one. I’m opening this up to anyone who’d like me to take a look at their equity, give them a report, and send monthly updates in between. Book a quick call with me and let’s get yours started.
Why owners hold so much more
Three things build an owner’s wealth:
- Forced savings. Every mortgage payment pays down principal, whether you feel like saving or not.
- A small down payment. You own the whole house with it, so price growth applies to the full value, not just your cash.
- Appreciation. National home prices have risen about 4.3% a year since 1991, based on the FHFA index.
The median owner has $230,000 in net housing value, according to the Fed.
One caution. The gap doesn’t prove owning caused all of it. Owners skew older and earn more, and both build wealth on their own. Treat the 43 times as a reason to run your own numbers, and don’t treat it as a promise.
What equity is and how return on equity works
Equity is what your house is worth minus what you owe. Return on equity (ROE) is what that equity earns in a year when the house gains value: the change in the house’s value divided by your equity today.
Take a $559,000 house with a $380,000 loan at 3.0% from 2021. After 64 payments, the balance is $334,803, so equity is $224,197, or 40.1% of the value. Your equity earns when the house appreciates, and it earns on the whole house, not just your share.
| What the house does | Change in value | Return on equity |
|---|---|---|
| Falls 0.79% (Dallas trend) | -$4,416 | -1.97% |
| Stays flat | $0 | 0% |
| Rises 2.1% (U.S. trend) | $11,739 | 5.24% |
| Rises 4% | $22,360 | 9.97% |
In a flat year, the house earns nothing on your equity. A high-yield savings account pays 4.35% (Bankrate, Nov. 7, 2026), so the house needs about 1.7% price growth in a year to match it.
Your payments also cut what you owe, by $9,308 over the next 12 months. That’s forced savings, and it’s a real benefit of owning. It’s your own money moving into the house, so I don’t count it as a return.
Want your starting number before you run the math? Type your address below. You’ll see an estimate in about 30 seconds, and you don’t need an email to see it. The estimate is a ballpark from public data, and the call is where I get it right.
Is owning a home a good investment? The 10-year math
Here’s the same $224,197 over 10 more years, left in the house or put somewhere else. The house’s value is in parentheses. The house rows add the house’s price change to today’s equity and leave out the principal you pay down. Taxes, selling costs, and withdrawals are left out too.
| Where the equity goes | Equity in 10 years | Yearly return |
|---|---|---|
| House falls 0.79% a year (house worth $516,376) | $181,573 | -2.09% |
| House stays flat (house worth $559,000) | $224,197 | 0% |
| House rises 2.1% a year, U.S. trend (house worth $688,128) | $353,325 | 4.65% |
| House rises 4.29% a year, the average since 1991 (house worth $850,822) | $516,019 | 8.69% |
| S&P 500 at its 30-year average of 10.4% | $603,005 | 10.4% |
| S&P 500 at 7% | $441,030 | 7.0% |
| S&P 500 repeats 2000 to 2009 | $203,992 | -0.94% |
| High-yield savings account at 4.35% | $343,206 | 4.35% |
The house needs about 1.95% price growth a year to beat a high-yield savings account. It takes about 3.33% a year to match a 7% market, and about 5.31% a year to match the S&P 500’s 30-year average. The house earns on its full value. At 2.1% a year, it gains 23.1% in 10 years, and your equity gains 57.6% from price growth alone.
The S&P 500 rows are historical averages, not a forecast. The 2000 to 2009 row shows what a bad decade does: the index lost about 9% in total, and your $224,197 turns into $203,992. Pick the growth rate you honestly expect for your house, find it in the table, and compare it with the S&P rows.
Leave it, pay it down, or redeploy it
You have three moves with your equity:
- Leave it. It keeps growing with the house, plus the principal you pay down. This is the default.
- Pay the loan down faster. Every extra dollar saves you in long-term interest.
- Redeploy it. Pull equity out and invest it. I covered that in should you use home equity to invest in the stock market and how to access home equity without losing your low rate.
Say you have an extra $1,000 a month for 10 years and a 3.0% loan. Here’s where it ends up:
| Where the $1,000 a month goes | Worth in 10 years |
|---|---|
| Extra payments on the 3.0% loan | $139,741 |
| High-yield savings account at 4.35% | $149,331 |
| S&P 500 at 10.4% | $204,083 |
| S&P 500 repeats 2000 to 2009 | $114,553 |
The loan row is how much less you’d owe in 10 years: the $120,000 you paid in plus $19,741 of interest you avoid. Anything that earns more than 3.0% beats the loan, and the high-yield savings account clears it even after tax. Paying down the loan is the only row with a guaranteed result. If your loan is closer to 7.11% than 3.0%, paying it down is a guaranteed 7.11%, more than a high-yield savings account or the 10-year Treasury at 4.86% (Nov. 6, 2026), and the answer flips. Look up your loan rate before you decide.
What this comparison leaves out
- Principal paydown. Your payments cut what you owe, which builds equity but comes out of your own pocket, so it’s not counted as a return here.
- Rent you don’t pay. Return on equity ignores it, and it’s real money in the house’s favor.
- Costs of owning. Property tax, insurance, and maintenance aren’t in these numbers, and they pull the house’s return down.
- Taxes. Up to $250,000 of gain ($500,000 married filing jointly) on your main home can be tax-free if you owned and lived in it at least 24 of the last 60 months. S&P 500 gains outside a retirement account are taxed.
- Your loan rate. A 3.0% loan is rare today. Most new buyers borrow at 7.11%.
Add the ones that apply to you before you act on any single row.
Where to start
Your house earns on your equity when it appreciates. Over 10 years, it beats a high-yield savings account at about 2% price growth a year and needs about 5.3% a year to match the S&P 500’s 30-year average. Forced savings and the rent you don’t pay build your wealth on top of that. Whether that’s enough depends on the growth you expect and the loan rate you pay.
Start with two numbers. Pull your loan balance and rate from your latest statement, get your home value, and subtract to find your equity. Then find your growth rate in the 10-year table.
Book a quick call with me and we’ll work out what your equity is earning and what it could earn instead. This is Part 1 of a series on your equity. Part 2 looks at why the S&P 500 can come out ahead on price growth alone and owners still end up richer.
Frequently asked questions
Is owning a home a good investment?
Owners hold about 43 times the wealth of renters, per the Fed’s 2025 survey, but the house isn’t the whole reason. Your return depends on price growth. In my $559,000 example, the house needs about 2% growth a year to beat a high-yield savings account and about 5.3% to match the S&P 500’s 30-year average over 10 years.
What is return on equity in real estate?
It’s what your equity earns in a year from the house gaining value. Divide the change in value by your equity today. In my example, a 2.1% price rise earns 5.24% on $224,197 of equity.
What’s a good return on equity for a house?
Compare it with your alternatives. A high-yield savings account pays 4.35%, and the S&P 500’s 30-year average is 10.4%. In my example, matching the savings account takes about 1.7% price growth in a year.
Should I pay off my mortgage early or invest?
Compare your loan rate with what the money could earn. Paying down a 3.0% loan saves you a guaranteed 3.0% in interest, and a 4.35% high-yield savings account beats it even after tax. If your loan is near 7.11%, paying it down is the better guarantee.
Are DFW home prices falling?
Dallas-area prices fell 0.79% over the year ending August 2026, per Case-Shiller, while U.S. prices rose 2.1%. Prices vary by neighborhood, so check your own.
Not sure what your equity looks like right now? Check it here.
Math notes: $559,000 house, $380,000 30-year loan at 3.0% from 2021, 64 payments made. Balance $334,803, equity $224,197 (40.1%), principal and interest $1,602 a month. Return on equity is the change in the house’s value divided by equity today. Principal paid in the next 12 months ($9,308) is shown separately and not counted as a return, though many real estate investors include it when they calculate return on equity for rentals. Case-Shiller Dallas -0.79% and U.S. +2.1% are year-over-year through August 2026. The 10-year view compounds each rate on the same $224,197 with no taxes, fees, or withdrawals. The house rows add the house’s price change to today’s equity and leave out principal paydown. Break-even price growth over 10 years is 1.95% against savings, 3.33% against a 7% market, and 5.31% against 10.4%. The 4.29% a year since 1991 is my arithmetic from the FHFA purchase-only index (100.00 in January 1991, 442.53 in June 2026). The S&P 500 10.4% is its 1996 to 2025 average annual return (Fidelity). The 2000 to 2009 row uses the decade’s total loss of about 9%, or -0.94% a year compounded. The $1,000-a-month table assumes level monthly deposits for 120 months, with the savings and S&P 500 annual rates converted to monthly rates. The loan row is the reduction in your balance at 3.0%: $120,000 paid plus $19,741 of interest avoided. After-tax savings math uses a 22% rate, which means a savings account needs to pay about 3.85% before tax to match a 3.0% loan. Mortgage rate 7.11% (Freddie Mac, Nov. 12, 2026). High-yield savings 4.35% is the best rate on Bankrate’s list (Nov. 7, 2026), and the national average is 0.57%. 10-year Treasury 4.86% (Nov. 6, 2026). Sources: Federal Reserve, 2025 Survey of Consumer Finances release (Oct. 9, 2026), Fed SCF report, Table 2, FHFA House Price Index, S&P Cotality Case-Shiller (Aug. 2026), Freddie Mac PMMS, Bankrate savings rates, Advisor Perspectives Treasury yields, Fidelity, A Wealth of Common Sense on the 2000s, IRS Topic 701, BiggerPockets on principal paydown.
