What Not to Fix When Selling a House: How to Answer the Buyer’s Repair Request

Home inspector with a clipboard examining a brick North Texas home, with the headline What Not to Fix When You Sell

You’re under contract. Then the buyer’s inspection report shows up with 70 pages and dozens of items marked “Deficient,” followed by a repair request that reads like a remodeling plan. The outlet that’s never worked. The cracked tile by the back door. Things you didn’t know your house had.

If you’re still getting ready to list, start with last week’s post on what home improvements add value. This one picks up after you’re under contract and helps you decide what not to fix when selling a house once the repair request lands.

Almost every seller gets one, because every house has a list, brand-new ones included. It’s hard because the clock is running. During the option period, the buyer can walk away for any reason and get their earnest money back. Without a plan, most sellers either say yes to everything and overpay, or dig in on everything and lose the buyer.

Here’s how I sort a repair request. Every item goes in one of three piles: fix it, offer a seller credit, or leave it. I’ll start with the pile that can kill your sale, then the one you can negotiate, then everything you can say no to.

The easiest way to avoid a long repair request is to take care of the important things before you list your home for sale. If you’re curious where to start, I have a residential construction certification and appraiser training, so I can tell you which items actually matter and which ones you can ignore. Click below to book a quick call with me before you list your house.

Fix it

This is the pile that can kill your sale: things the inspection turned up that you didn’t know about. Safety issues, things that make the house hard to insure, and anything that’s broken.

Lenders draw the same line. Fannie Mae won’t accept a house with a problem that affects safety, soundness, or structural integrity until it’s repaired. FHA and VA appraisers in Texas look hard at the roof. And no lender will close a loan without homeowners insurance.

Also, in Texas, nobody has to make repairs unless both sides agree in writing, including repairs the buyer’s lender requires. It is a common misconception that lender-required repairs are things the seller has to do. What that statement really means is the lender requires these repairs to be done in order to finance the loan. In some cases, the buyer can cover them through a repair escrow or a renovation loan. It just has more hoops to jump through.

And, if no one agrees to pay for those, the contract ends and the buyer gets their earnest money back. If the lender’s repairs would cost more than 5% of the price, about $27,950 on a $559,000 house, the buyer can walk away.

There’s one more reason to take this pile seriously. Once the inspection tells you about a defect, Texas law requires you to disclose it to the next buyer if this one walks. You do this as an update to the seller disclosure.

The roof and the big systems

In Texas, insurers look hardest at the roof, the wiring, the heating and air conditioning, the plumbing, and the siding. Those are the parts the Texas Department of Insurance says companies can judge by condition. An insurer can’t turn down a house just because the roof or those systems are old, but it can if they’re in bad shape. Some only cover older roofs at their depreciated value. If the inspector flagged any of these, get a licensed pro out to look before you respond.

Fix windows and doors that are actually broken, like a door that won’t latch or a window that won’t close or lock. A small crack in a pane usually isn’t a lender or insurance problem, so it can go in the credit pile.

The foundation

Shifting foundations are common in North Texas, and a little movement doesn’t scare most buyers. A foundation that’s obviously broken is different. It takes almost every buyer who wants a move-in-ready house off the table, and you’re left selling to investors at investor prices.

Zillow found that homes listed as fixer-uppers sold for 14% less than expected. On a $559,000 house, that’s about $78,000. Fixing the foundation may cost far less than that discount, and some foundation companies will finance the repair or wait to be paid at closing. Get a couple of bids before you respond.

Offer a seller credit

These are the repair requests you’re willing to consider but may not want to handle yourself. That’s when a seller credit comes in handy as a negotiating tool.

A seller credit is money you credit back to the buyer at closing to help with their closing costs, instead of doing the repair yourself.

This pile is for cosmetic items that probably should be replaced but still work: dirty or worn carpet, cracked tile, chipped LVP, dated fixtures. You can still use them. They’re just an eyesore.

Here’s the catch. In my experience, you’ll normally pay more in a seller credit than you would to actually get the repair done. A credit is a great option if you don’t have the time or the resources to get repairs done before closing. If you do, you can probably save money by making the repairs you agree to yourself, with licensed contractors and receipts.

The trick to saving money is to base the credit on real quotes from contractors you trust. Don’t let the buyer’s estimate inflate the cost.

How a seller credit actually works

On a conventional loan, you can’t hand the buyer cash for repairs. Fannie Mae only lets seller money go toward the buyer’s closing costs, prepaids, and HOA dues. So a “repair credit” is really a closing-cost credit, or a lower price.

There’s also a cap, and it depends on the buyer’s down payment. With less than 10% down, the cap is 3% of the price, about $16,770 on a $559,000 house, and closing costs may already be using some of it. Ask the buyer’s agent what the loan allows before you offer a credit.

A credit at closing can also go further for the buyer than a price cut. If they use it to buy down their interest rate, $10,000 saves a buyer putting 20% down about $168 a month at the Oct. 29 average of 7.24%. The same $10,000 as a price cut saves about $55. Point pricing varies by lender, but the buydown came out ahead at every point value I ran. Use that when you offer the credit.

Leave it

This pile is everything that didn’t fit in the first two, and it’s usually safe to decline.

It met code when it was built

Almost every Texas inspection report marks a few things “Deficient” on a perfectly good house. Missing GFCI outlets near sinks, no arc-fault breakers, no anti-tip bracket behind the range. Texas inspectors are required to flag these, and the report itself says a deficient item doesn’t obligate anyone to repair it. These things work perfectly fine as they are. They’re just not up to the current code, even though they met code when the house was built.

If one of these shows up on the repair request, you can usually decline it.

Personal preferences

Taste goes in this pile, too. The accent wall, the bold kitchen color, the light fixtures you picked because you love them. The buyer saw all of it before they made their offer. If it works and it’s in good shape, it’s a preference, and the buyer can change it after closing.

Decline requests that come down to taste.

Normal wear and easy maintenance

Holes in a window screen, a door that sticks, missing caulk, a loose cabinet hinge. Every lived-in house has these. Fannie Mae’s own guidelines list things like holes in screens as items that generally don’t need repair for a loan to close.

Decline the small stuff a homeowner handles in an afternoon.

Where to start

When the repair request comes in, don’t freak out or feel like you need to say yes to everything. This is where experience really matters, and a network of trusted contractors who can get you quotes fairly quickly.

The goal here is to be fair, but mainly to not lose the contract, while still protecting your equity and sanity.

Put every item in one of three columns. Fix, negotiate, and decline. Decline the code and taste items. Offer a credit for the cosmetic ones if you don’t have the time to fix them, or fix them yourself if you do. Get bids on everything in the Fix column, starting with the roof and the foundation.

This is where experience really matters. As your listing agent, I’ll go through the request with you line by line, sort it, and negotiate the response so you keep the buyer without overpaying.

Despite all of this, the best strategy is to take care of most of these items before you ever go onto the market. If you’re curious about my pre-listing strategy, book a call at the link below.

Frequently asked questions

What should you not fix when selling a house?

Items that met code when the house was built, like missing GFCI outlets, and anything that comes down to taste, like paint colors or fixtures. Both are usually safe to decline when the buyer’s repair request comes in.

Do I have to fix everything on a home inspection report in Texas?

No. A “Deficient” item on a Texas inspection report doesn’t obligate anyone to repair it. Repairs are whatever you and the buyer agree to in writing.

What repairs are mandatory when selling a house in Texas?

None, unless you agree to them in writing. That includes repairs the buyer’s lender requires. If neither side agrees to pay for those, the contract ends and the buyer gets their earnest money back.

Is it better to give a seller credit or make repairs?

If you have the time and resources, making the repairs yourself usually costs less. A seller credit makes sense when you can’t get the work done before closing.

Can a seller give a buyer cash for repairs?

Not on a conventional loan. Fannie Mae lets seller money go only toward the buyer’s closing costs, prepaids, and HOA dues, so a “repair credit” becomes a closing-cost credit or a lower price.

Got a repair request in hand? Book a strategy session here.

Curious how far a seller credit stretches for a buyer? Read rate buydown vs. price reduction for the full math.


Math notes: Example house is $559,000, the median close price of 262 single-family sales from $400,000 to $700,000 in Haslet, Keller, and Saginaw, May 1 to Oct. 26, 2026 (NTREIS). Seller-credit caps: 3% above 90% LTV, 6% from 75.01% to 90%, 9% at 75% or less (Fannie Mae B3-4.1-02). 3% of $559,000 = $16,770. Buydown vs. price cut: 20% down ($447,200 loan), 30-year fixed at 7.24% (Freddie Mac PMMS, Oct. 29, 2026). $10,000 buys 2.24 points at 1 point ≈ 0.25% off the rate (rule of thumb, varies by lender): rate to about 6.68%, P&I from $3,048 to $2,880 (−$168). A $10,000 price cut lowers the loan by $8,000: P&I to $2,993 (−$55). At 0.15% to 0.30% per point, the buydown saves $101 to $201 a month. 5% of $559,000 = $27,950 (TREC One to Four Family Residential Contract, form 20-19, effective July 1, 2026). Fixer-upper discount: 14% of $559,000 = $78,260 (Zillow, 2M+ 2025 listings, sale price vs. expected price by listing language, Mar. 24, 2026). Sources: Freddie Mac PMMS, Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-02, May 7, 2025, Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-06, June 4, 2025, TREC form 20-19, TREC inspection report form REI 7-6, 22 Tex. Admin. Code 535.229, Texas Property Code 5.008, seller’s disclosure, TDI on roof, wiring, HVAC, plumbing, and siding condition, Sept. 29, 2026, Zillow 2026 home features research, Mar. 24, 2026.

Similar Posts