You’ve got a list of projects and a budget that won’t cover all of them. The TV shows make it look easy: knock out a wall, add a farmhouse sink, tell a few bad jokes, and voila, the house is suddenly worth a fortune.
Unfortunately, real life rarely works out that neatly. The question I get most is simple: what home improvements add value, and which ones just cost money? Everyone has an opinion, from your neighbor to the guy at the hardware store. The biggest mistake I see is starting with your own wish list instead of what buyers in your neighborhood actually paid for.
Here’s how we’re going to tackle this. First, how an appraiser sees your upgrade, and why your competition comes first. Then the three buckets: projects that pay you in enjoyment, projects that pay you partly, and projects that pay you back. Then what borrowing at 7% does to the math, and when to DIY.
How an appraiser sees your upgrade
Appraisers don’t value receipts. They compare your house to recent sales nearby and adjust for the differences buyers actually paid for.
Two ratings drive a lot of that. Condition runs from C1 (new) to C6 (major repairs needed). Quality runs from Q1 to Q6 and covers materials and workmanship. An appraiser also notes whether your kitchen and baths are “updated,” meaning brought up to current expectations without major changes, or “remodeled,” meaning significant changes like moving plumbing or adding square footage.
The appraisal form itself is changing. Starting Nov. 2, 2026, new appraisals rate the interior and exterior separately. Expect your curb appeal to carry its own grade, so fix what shows from the street.
Start by looking at your competition
Before you pick a project, look at the homes in your neighborhood that sold for the price you want. Compare your house to theirs, room by room. Look at the countertops. Did they have a backsplash? What kind of sinks or fixtures? What was the flooring like? How did their paint look? Really pick it apart, matching feature for feature.
When you compare your house to the competition the way a buyer would, a lot of times you’ll find it doesn’t need as much work as you originally thought.
The nicest kitchen on the street still gets compared to the other kitchens on the street, and valued like the rest of the neighborhood. This is where an expert opinion really comes in handy. A paired sales analysis (kitchen for kitchen, pool or no pool) can be tricky if you’ve never done one before. Look at what’s for sale, and call a real estate agent to pull the recent sales near you before you call a contractor.
Pays you in enjoyment: the big projects
These are the projects people love living with, and they get back the smallest share of their cost. From the 2025 Cost vs. Value report for our region (Texas, Oklahoma, Arkansas, and Louisiana):
| Project | Average cost (U.S.) | Share recouped, our region |
|---|---|---|
| Primary suite addition (upscale) | $351,613 | 18% |
| Solar panels* | $55,937 | 30% |
| Primary suite addition (midrange) | $170,517 | 33% |
| Major kitchen remodel (upscale) | $164,104 | 35% |
| Major kitchen remodel (midrange) | $82,793 | 51% |
*Survey estimate from 2025. In my experience, and from talking with other agents and appraisers, it’s very rare for solar panels to actually add value to a house, especially when they’re financed or leased.
Solar got harder this year. The 30% federal tax credit ended for systems installed after Dec. 31, 2025. If your panels are financed or leased, in my experience the real number is closer to zero. Most buyers are either unwilling or unable to bring extra cash to pay off the solar panels or take over your loan or lease at closing, so most sellers end up paying for the panels out of their closing proceeds.
Pools are still adding value right now, though at a much lower share of the cost, usually somewhere around 20% to 30%. They do help a house sell faster, especially in the summer months. They also add to your property tax bill. In Texas, a new improvement gets added to your taxable value on top of the 10% yearly cap on homesteads.
If you’re staying 10 years and you’ll use it every day, these can be the right call. Do them for you, and don’t count on the resale.
Pays you partly: do these because the house needs them
| Project | Average cost (U.S.) | Share recouped, our region |
|---|---|---|
| Asphalt roof replacement | $31,871 | 68% |
| Vinyl window replacement | $22,073 | 71% |
| Bath remodel (midrange) | $26,138 | 81% |
The payback on these doesn’t always show up in the appraisal. It shows up in the deal holding together. An old roof can also make a house hard to insure, and a buyer can’t close a loan without insurance.
In one of my recent listings, the sellers spent about $3,000 before listing on minor HVAC maintenance, roof maintenance, and a few other small projects around the house. Once they were under contract, the buyers asked for almost no repairs. That made the process much smoother right at the point where buyers normally walk away over repairs and surprise fixes.
If a system is near the end of its life, take care of it before a buyer’s inspector finds it.
Pays you back: small and seen from the curb
| Project | Average cost (U.S.) | Share recouped, our region |
|---|---|---|
| Minor kitchen remodel (midrange) | $28,458 | 117% |
| Steel entry door | $2,435 | 234% |
| Garage door replacement | $4,672 | 270% |
Entry doors and garage doors are known for adding value and curb appeal, and they’re the cheapest projects on the list. A minor kitchen refresh is the one inside project that comes out ahead, but only if your kitchen needs it. In the report, that’s new cabinet fronts and hardware, new laminate counters, a new sink, appliances, and flooring, all in the same layout.
You’ll also see manufactured stone veneer near the top of this report. That project replaces vinyl siding on the lower third of the front of a house with stone. I can’t imagine buyers here paying that much more for it, so I’d leave it off your list.
Start at the curb and the kitchen, and stop there unless you’re doing it for yourself.
The 7% test: borrowing changes the math
The average HELOC rate was 7.36% on Oct. 21, 2026. Put the $28,458 minor kitchen on a HELOC and sell in three years:
| Minor kitchen on a HELOC | Amount |
|---|---|
| Value added (117%) | $33,381 |
| Project cost | -$28,458 |
| HELOC interest, 3 years | -$6,284 |
| Added property taxes, 3 years | -$1,756 |
| Net | -$3,116 |
In other words, the best-paying inside project loses money once you borrow for it and sell soon. Pay cash for improvements, or plan to stay long enough for you to enjoy them.
DIY or hire it out?
When you’re getting ready to sell, a lot of guys think it’s time to dust off the tools they haven’t touched in a few years and knock out the list they’ve been avoiding. I’m not hating on my DIY people out there. I’m one of them myself. But when you’re getting ready to sell, only DIY the projects you’ve done before and know you can do right.
Buyers can almost always spot DIY work or things that don’t look quite right, and if they don’t, their inspector will. Buyers also want a warranty, and you can’t give one on your own work.
Permits matter, too. Fort Worth requires them for plumbing (including water heaters), electrical, HVAC, pools, and remodels. Keller and Haslet require them for fences. Texas’s seller disclosure asks whether any work was done without the permits it needed. Call your city before you start, and hire it out for anything a buyer’s inspector will open up.
Choose wisely
The projects that add the most value are usually smaller and cheaper than you’d expect. Before you spend a dollar, look at what the homes that sold for your target price actually had, and match that first. Start at the curb, take care of anything the house needs, and save the big projects for the ones you’ll love living with. Pay cash where you can, and hire out anything a buyer’s inspector will open up.
Frequently asked questions
What home improvements add the most value?
The small, visible ones. In the 2025 Cost vs. Value report for our region, a garage door replacement recouped about 270% of its cost, a steel entry door about 234%, and a midrange minor kitchen remodel about 117%.
What home improvements do not add value?
The biggest ones get back the least. An upscale primary suite addition recouped about 18% of its cost in our region, an upscale kitchen remodel about 35%, and solar panels about 30%.
Does a new roof add value to an appraisal?
It recouped about 68% of its cost in our region. Its bigger job is keeping the house insurable and keeping buyers from walking away over repairs.
Does a pool add value to your home in Texas?
Usually some, but far less than it costs, about 20% to 30% of the cost right now. A pool can help a house sell faster in the summer, and it raises your property taxes.
Do solar panels add value to a home in Texas?
Rarely. The 2025 Cost vs. Value survey put them at about 30% of cost in our region, but in my experience, and from talking with other agents and appraisers, it’s very rare for solar panels to actually add value, especially when they’re financed or leased. The 30% federal tax credit also ended for systems installed after Dec. 31, 2025.
Want to know what your house is worth before you spend on it? Get your home’s value here.
Thinking about the roof first? Read why homeowners insurance is so expensive in Texas for what your roof does to your premium.
Math notes and sources
Math notes: Costs are national averages and percentages are for the West South Central region (Texas, Oklahoma, Arkansas, Louisiana) in the Zonda/JLC Cost vs. Value 2025 report, released Sept. 18, 2025. That report estimates what a project adds to resale value in its first year, based on surveys of real estate professionals. It’s not appraisal data, and your house and street will differ. Pool range is Kiel’s read of the current local market. 7% test: interest-only HELOC draw at 7.36% (Bankrate national average, Oct. 21, 2026) for 3 years. Added taxes use Keller’s 2026 rates with a homestead exemption, about 1.75% of added value a year (Tarrant County Truth-in-Taxation Summary, Sept. 30, 2026). Interest may be tax-deductible if you itemize and the loan was used to improve the home (IRS Pub. 936).
Sources:
- Cost vs. Value 2025, West South Central
- Cost vs. Value 2025, manufactured stone veneer
- Cost vs. Value 2025, minor kitchen remodel
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-06, condition and quality ratings
- Freddie Mac UAD redesign FAQ
- IRS FAQ on the end of 25C and 25D
- Bankrate HELOC rates
- Tarrant County Truth-in-Taxation Summary
- City of Fort Worth permit guide
- City of Keller permits
- City of Haslet FAQ
- TREC Seller’s Disclosure Notice 55-1
- IRS Pub. 936
